Anal / Erotic Stories / Group Sex · October 22, 2021

First Time Threesome Part -1

Kate was one of Mary’s best friends. They went to the same schools, had the same friends and played the same sports all through their lives. Basically, everything they did growing up was together.

Kate was a very attractive girl. She was small, athletic, and had long dark black hair. Mary always said Kate was the friend all the guys would hit on. I can’t say I didn’t have a few dirty thoughts about her but she didn’t come close to Mary. To this day, if someone asked me to pick between them, I would pick Mary one hundred out of one hundred times.

I had met Kate years before but over the time I was dating Mary I got to know her a little better. The first time I got to see her wild side was at the previous years Halloween party. Mary and Kate’s friends always threw this big shindig every Halloween. There were people that I knew and a bunch of people I had never met.

At that point in time, Kate had just went through a pretty tough breakup.

That night she was doing her best to drink all her sorrows away.

Meanwhile, Mary had a few drinks and I barely drank at all, since I was driving us home.

Mary had wanted us to dress as a couple that evening and she decided on a funny looking killer-whale costume. I couldn’t really think of anything to go with it so I dressed as Captain Ahab from Moby Dick – I figured most people wouldn’t know the difference anyways! Kate was dressed as a Playboy Bunny. She even had the little tail and bunny ears but they kept falling off of her head.

After a few hours we decided to head home. I didn’t tell Mary about seeing Kate make-out with a bunch of different people, including two other women. She was totally hammered by the time we got her into the car. On the ride home Mary leaned over to give me a quick kiss while we were stopped at a red light.

“Someone is getting their blow-hole stuffed tonight!” Mary drunkenly said from the backseat.

That got a chuckle from all of us.

When we got to her place Mary insisted that I carry Kate inside. I scooped her up in my arms and carried her to the front door. Mary pushed it open for us.

“I’m gonna use the bathroom real quick. That beer ran through me.” she told us, heading off towards the bathroom.

I made my way to her bedroom, placing her down onto the bed.

As I was leaving she reached out and took hold of my left hand.

“Hey! Come here.” Kate whispered.

“What’s up? You okay?” I asked.

Kate pulled my face down to hers and planted a kiss on my mouth. I felt her tongue force it’s way into my mouth before I could step back.

“Woah there killer. You’re way too drunk.” I said.

“No I’m not! I want to get stuffed too!” she told me.

With that verbiage, I tried not to break out laughing. I looked her directly in the eyes, “Mary is your best friend. We can’t do that to her.”

“She can join us!” she managed to slobber out, before passing out.

I closed her bedroom door and walked to the front of the house.

“She okay?” Mary asked.

“She’ll be fine.” I answered back.

On the ride home I told Mary about the kiss. Thankfully, she laughed and said she’s seen Kate do worse.

“I’m surprised you didn’t take her up on the offer. Most guys would. She’s beautiful” she told me.

“Not as beautiful as you are.” I said back, which made Mary smile.

“Besides, she’s way too messed up. I would’ve felt like I took advantage of her like that.”

Mary leaned over and gave me a kiss on the cheek as we pulled into the driveway.

*****

That following December.

Mary and I decided we needed a break from everything. We decided to rent a cabin for a weekend getaway. She was tired from all the work she had to do to get her degree and I needed to get away from my job as well.

The day before we were supposed to leave she got a message from Kate. She was wondering if she could stay with us for the weekend.

I was hoping for non-stop sex the whole time with Mary but I acquiesced and told her it was fine. Kate met us at my house after we had all gotten off of work.

We drove about an hour away to the cabin. We arrived around six in the evening that Friday. It was a pleasant little place. We purposely got one of the smallest cabins the company offered but we didn’t expect to have a third person with us.

The place only had one bathroom and one bedroom but it did have a nice little hot tub that was walled in by windows.

We were pretty isolated, up on a mountain, surrounded by trees with just the peace, quiet and the cold to keep us company.

That first night went pretty fast. We got everything unpacked and put up. We got food on the way in so we just chilled and watched a movie. I’ve always thought it was ironic people wanted to go to these places to get away but somehow the cabins always had a TV and internet.

When it was bedtime, I offered to use the couch so Kate and Mary could have the bed, but Kate was super cool about everything. She wouldn’t accept my offer. She took the couch which allowed me to be with Mary.

The next morning we woke around nine in the morning. It wasn’t too chilly so we decided to go on a hike. We stuck to the marked trails, coming across beautiful, snowy scenery everywhere we looked. Nature has always been such a calm and beautiful place to me.

At one point we stumbled across a waterfall. It was probably a solid seventy-five feet above us. Some of the water as frozen but most was pouring down into the creek below.

“You guys want to skinny-dip?” Kate asked.

“You’re crazy! You’d freeze in there.” Mary laughed.

“That’s what the hot tub is for!” Kate shot back.

They both looked at me. “You ladies can but I’m good.”

“Man, you guys are wimps!” Kate laughed.

After a few hours of exploring we walked back. We all decided to take a nap for a few hours. When I awoke I heard the shower running. I looked over, noticing Mary wasn’t there. The bedroom door was shut so I didn’t think much about checking to see if Kate was still asleep. This was my first chance at some action. I slid open the bathroom door. The room was so full of steam I could barely make out anything. That’s when I heard some giggling coming from the shower. I thought it was just Mary but I opened the curtain to see two amazing, beautiful bodies. Both Mary and Kate screamed.

I panicked and ran back to the bedroom.

A couple of minutes later, they came out with towels wrapped around their bodies and their wet hair hanging free.

“I’m sorry.” I told Kate. “I didn’t know you were in there.”

“It’s okay. I’m sure it’s not the first pair of boobs you’ve seen.” She laughed and walked into the living room.

I turned to Mary, who was also laughing. She explained that since there was only one bathroom, they decided to take a shower together. Something they had been doing since they were kids.

“We’ve played sports together since we were like twelve! I’ve seen her naked plenty of times.” she said with a wink and a smile..

Thankfully, we had enough foresight to bring groceries with us but, of course, we forget the basic stuff. The only store close by was a small gas station that everyone had to pass on the way in. The ladies decided to go and get all the stuff we forgot. I turned on the grill and began cooking the burgers. They were gone, maybe twenty-five minutes total. When they came back with the supplies I noticed they had a few packs of beer with them. That wasn’t too surprising per se but we already had a couple bottles of wine on the counter. I didn’t plan on drinking that much.

While we had dinner, we each had a few of the beers.

Around eight they decided we should take a dip in the hot tub.

We went to get into our swimming attire. I watched Mary undress as I was putting on my shorts. Her body was just magnificent. Her white two-piece bikini curved in all the right places.

We made our way outside to see Kate already in the hot tub. She had on a similar bikini but hers was black.

We talked, laughed and drank for what seemed like hours.

Around ten I heard, “Let’s play Truth or Dare!”

I looked over to see Kate holding a beer in her hand, smiling.

Mary turned to look at me, a smile forming on her face.

“I’m game if your are. She’s your friend.” I said, putting out my right arm around her shoulders to pull her closer to me.

“Okay then, who goes first?” Mary asked.

“I will.” Kate answered almost immediately. “We each have to ask the other two at least once.”

“Truth or Dare?” she asked me.

“Really? Of course I have to go first. Well, I’m still a little too sober so I’m gonna go with Truth.”

“Was Mary really your first?” Kate asked, laughing, but also being serious at the same time.

I nodded my head. “She was. I was a little embarrassed when I was younger but I’m an old man now. I couldn’t be happier that she was my first.”

“Ahhhhh.” Kate sighed out.

Mary leaned over to kiss me on the cheek.

“Ooh! It’s my turn now!” Mary smiled. “Truth or Dare, Kate?”

“Pffffft! Dare, of course.” she answered back.

“I dare you to take off your bikini top and throw it away from the hot tub!”

I wasn’t expecting that at all. I figured we would still need a few more beers before anyone got naked.

Kate sat her beer down, unclasped her top, and threw it back towards the living room. The top of her breasts were level with the water while her nipples were barely visible underneath.

“Dangit! I meant for you to show your boobs!” Mary laughed.

Kate then stood up. She didn’t have the biggest breasts but her B-cup was nice and perky. They went well with her toned abs and fit body.

Mary began running her left hand up and down my right thigh, under the water.

“Umm, now it’s my turn isn’t it?” Both women turned to look at me.

I’m sure Mary was a little nervous. I imagined her thinking I would dare her to to do something with Kate.

“Truth or Dare, Mary?” I asked, giving her a funny look.

To my surprise, she answered “Dare.”

“I dare you to take off your bikini top AND bottoms and throw them away from the hot tub!”

She stood up, releasing her magnificent breasts, before sitting back down and peeling off her bottoms, under the water. She threw her bikini in the same direction as Kate did.

“Man, you have perfect boobs!” Kate said to Mary.

“Gee thanks! Coming from miss flat stomach over there!” Mary laughed.

I had seen her topless many times but I couldn’t stop looking. Mary’s sex appeal was beyond anything I could have ever imagined. She truly had the body of a goddess.

All of a sudden Mary and Kate pulled me to my feet.

They each took a handful on each side of my shorts and ripped them down so fast I couldn’t react fast enough. I immediately sat back down.

“Oh, don’t be a party pooper!” You look like you were enjoying the fun!” Kate laughed, before sitting back down.

I was hoping she hadn’t noticed but of course she had. Seeing both of them topless and with Mary rubbing my leg, I was rocking a huge hard-on by that point.

“Get back up here!” Mary pulled me back to my feet, my rock-hard penis sticking straight out.

Both women laughed hysterically as Mary and I sat back down.

After she caught her breath from laughing, Mary snuggled back up next to me. I wrapped my right arm back around her shoulders, this time she started using her left hand to softly caress my penis under the water.

I’m almost certain Kate could pick up on the action going on down there.

“Well, since I’m the only one, I guess I’ll take these off.” Kate said, bending forward in the water to remove her bottoms.

We all sat completely naked now.

“Now I have to ask you, Mary!” Kate said smiling over at her friend.

“Truth or Dare?”

“Dare!” Mary answered fiercely.

“You always talk about how good of a kisser he is. I dare you to kiss him in front of me. But not just a little kiss. I want to see you make-out! I want to see open mouths and tongues twirling!”